Here’s an overview of the Best Mechanical Pencils that we’ll explore today:
Mechanical pencils matter for everyday writing, drafting, and precision work because they combine consistent line quality with reusable lead, reducing interruptions from sharpening. In this review, I test and compare five widely available 0.7 mm HB/number-two lead pencils across a range of price points and designs to reveal how build quality, lead performance, erasing capability, grip comfort, and accessory inclusions translate into real-world value. My evaluation criteria include: lead smoothness and smudge resistance, lead durability and breakage resistance, ease of lead advance and erasing, grip comfort during long sessions, reliability of the mechanism (refillable and retractable design), and total cost of ownership (lead capacity and accessory availability). The products span budget-friendly sets to recognizable brands, offering insights for students, professionals, and artists alike.
1. BIC Xtra Smooth Mechanical Pencil with 0.7 mm Medium Point
- Brand: BIC
- Manufacturer: BIC
Overview: This is a high-volume pack from BIC, marketed as a dependable everyday writing tool with a 0.7 mm HB point, a retractable mechanism, and refillable lead. The 40-count packaging implies low per-unit cost and a ready supply for classrooms or teams. The product emphasizes smudge resistance and a simple click-to-advance lead system, leveraging BIC’s established reliability as a top-selling mechanical pencil brand in the U.S. The build uses a plastic barrel with ribbed grip and a retractable closure, keeping lead protected between uses. Prospective buyers will appreciate the value proposition: low per-pencil cost, consistent 0.7 mm lead, and the reassurance of a familiar, widely available refilling ecosystem.
Performance-wise, these pencils deliver predictable, dark HB lines with minimal smearing, suitable for note-taking, exams, and drafting rough sketches. The 40-count pack supports bulk use, though the trade-off is a relatively lightweight feel compared with metal-bodied pencils. The retractable mechanism reduces lead exposure and snag risk in pockets or pencil cases. For heavy users, the value proposition rests on availability of compatible BIC lead and erasers; however, the all-plastic construction means slightly less tactile weight and potentially less fatigue resistance during marathon writing sessions.
Pros
- Low per-pencil cost in a bulk 40-pack
- Reliable 0.7 mm HB lead with smooth writing
- Retractable design protects lead and reduces breakage risk
- Widely available BIC lead/refill ecosystem
- Smudge-resistant writing suitable for notes and exams
Cons
- Plastic barrel may feel cheaper and lighter than metal competitors
- No included eraser integration (some variants lack erasers)
- Grip may be less comfortable for long sessions
2. BIC Xtra Smooth Mechanical Pencil with Erasers
- Brand: BIC
- Manufacturer: BIC
Overview: This variant adds erasers to the 40-count pack, emphasizing clean corrections with an eraser-providing pencil alongside the familiar 0.7 mm HB lead. The packaging notes a smooth writing experience and a simple lead advancement mechanism, with a color-variant barrel aesthetic that can help with organization. The inclusion of an eraser reduces the need for separate supplies during school or office use, aligning with classroom practicality and teacher-friendly expectations.
In use, these pencils deliver consistent 0.7 mm HB lines with similar smudge resistance to the plain version. The eraser addition is helpful for quick corrections, though eraser quality can vary and may wear down with heavy erasing. The retractable design remains a strong point for portability, but as with many budget-friendly offerings, long-term wear on plastic components can affect feel and accuracy. The lead may still be prone to breakage on very hard presses or when using demanding drafting tasks.
Pros
- Includes erasers for quick corrections
- Maintains smooth 0.7 mm HB performance
- Bulk 40-count packaging for classrooms or offices
- Retraction mechanism protects lead
- Good value with added eraser utility
Cons
- Eraser quality can vary and may wear quickly
- Plastic construction may feel less premium
- Lead protection may still allow occasional lead breakage under heavy pressure
3. BIC Xtra Smooth Mechanical Pencil
- Brand: BIC
- Manufacturer: BIC
Overview: This is another BIC 40-count option, similar to Product 0 but with its own packaging identity and slightly different model numbers. It emphasizes the same core attributes: 0.7 mm HB lead, retractable mechanism, and a smooth, reliable writing experience. The multi-color/barrel option in this variant can aid organization in shared workspaces and classrooms. It reinforces BIC’s leadership in the mechanical pencil category with a focus on consistent performance and broad compatibility with standard HB lead.
Performance insights show consistent, clean lines with minimal smudge when paired with HB lead. The built-in erasing capability is straightforward, and the retractable function minimizes lead exposure. The polygonal/ergonomic grip texture contributes to steadiness during extended writing, though some users may notice a lighter overall weight due to the plastic construction. This model is well-suited for students and professionals who value dependable supply and uniform performance across large groups.
Pros
- Repeats the trusted 0.7 mm HB experience
- Retractable and refillable for longevity
- Multi-color barrel options aid differentiation
- Consistent performance with minimal smudge
- Ergonomic grip aids control
Cons
- Same plastic construction trade-offs as other budget models
- Erased lead performance depends on eraser quality
- No standout premium features
4. Paper Mate Clearpoint Mechanical Pencils
- Brand: Paper Mate
- Manufacturer: Paper Mate
Overview: Paper Mate’s Clearpoint line offers a slightly higher-end feature set in a compact two-pencil package, with 0.7 mm HB lead and side lead advancement. The assorted barrel colors add personality and help with individualization in shared environments. Notable features include a jumbo twist eraser and a soft grip, which prioritize erasing comfort and extended writing sessions. The side lead-advance mechanism can be more controlled for precise drafting needs.
In practice, the Clearpoint pencils deliver clean lines with reliable lead advancement and a notable emphasis on erasing convenience. The jumbo eraser, while not professional-grade, provides ample correction without frequent re-erasings. The side lead advance is a distinct ergonomics advantage for users who prefer not to rotate the pencil, though it can require deliberate handling to avoid accidental lead exposure. The dual-pencil package is ideal for students or artists who want quick access to two ready-to-use pencils with a touch of style.
Pros
- Side lead advance provides controlled dispensing
- Soft grip enhances comfort on longer writing sessions
- Jumbo eraser offers substantial correction capability
- Assorted barrel colors aid personalization
- Two-pencils per pack for immediate availability
Cons
- Higher price relative to single-pack budget options
- Some users may prefer a fully metal barrel
- Lead size remains 0.7 mm; no heavier-duty options
5. Four Candies 0.7mm Mechanical Pencil Set with Case – 4PCS Metal Mechanical Pencils
- Brand: Four Candies
- Manufacturer: Four Candies
Overview: This budget-friendly set from Four Candies stands out with a metal-bodied design and a comprehensive accessory bundle, including lead refills (HB #2), erasers, and multiple eraser refills, all housed in a compact case. The metal construction promises a more premium feel and improved weight distribution compared to plastic competitors. The replacement lead supply and eraser extras address long-term usability and reduce the need for frequent repurchases, making it a strong value proposition for artists and students who want more than just pencils.
Performance-wise, the metal barrels provide a sturdier, more balanced writing experience with better inertia control during long sessions. The 0.7 mm HB lead offers the expected dark line with smoothness, and the resin-based leads in the included tubes are designed to resist breakage under normal use. The ergonomics, aided by a polygonal barrel shape and a metal clip, reduce slipping on desktops. However, the set’s overall durability will depend on the quality of the included leads and erasers, which can vary batch-to-batch. This option is particularly attractive for students and hobbyists who want both performance and a broad accessory kit without paying premium brand pricing.
Pros
- Metal-bodied pencils offer better weight and balance
- Includes substantial lead refills and erasers
- Case provides organized transport and storage
- Polygonal barrel reduces slipping on desks
- Comprehensive value bundle for artists and students
Cons
- Lower absolute brand prestige vs. dedicated premium pencils
- Lead and erasers quality can vary by batch
- Bulk packaging may be less compact for tight pencil cases
Frequently Asked Questions
We’ve compiled answers to the most common questions about mechanical pencilss to help you make an informed decision.
Conclusion
Final thoughts: For the widest appeal and budget-conscious buyers, BIC’s 40-count Xtra Smooth packs remain hard to beat for value, consistency, and availability.
If you want more premium feel and durability, Four Candies’ metal pencils offer a compelling package with a durable construction and a rich accessory set.
Paper Mate Clearpoint is a strong middle-ground choice, especially for users who prize a side-advance mechanism and a cushioned grip. In practice, select based on build preference (plastic vs metal), accessory needs (erasers and leads), and how much you value ergonomics for extended writing or drawing sessions..